Re: AAP announcement tomorrow
Posted 3/21/2011 10:31:15 AM by jerseypanda


Posted by tarabelle99


Posted by AJandCJsMommy

while it's still a recommendation, if you read your car seat it is still 100% legal to FF them at 1 year and 20lbs.

i am just saying.... not trying to argue.. we as parents do what we feel is best for our children.... but Car Seat manuals and what is printed on Car seats is not obsolete and can still be followed



It's legal to FF them at 4 months if your car seat allows it. Not all car seats have 1&20 as the minimum requirement to FF, some only have a weight. Some have a height requirement too. NY laws only require that they be in a properly used seat until they are 4 and then be boostered to their 8th birthday.

LEGAL doesn't always mean SAFE.

Just saying



ITA. To give an analogy... It would have been perfectly legal for me to give my brother an entire bottle of vodka on his 21st birthday and dare him to drink the entire thing in 5 minutes. I know that studies will tell you that drinking too much alcohol in a short period of time can give you alcohol poisoning and could even cause death, but so what... people drink all the time, the chances of anything happening to my brother are slim. I'll take my chances. If he actually did it and ended up dying because he drank so much, I don't know how I could live with that guilt. It would have been totally legal, but not safe and I would be going against documented studies that have been done about people who drink too much too fast.

I feel the same way about the car seat thing. It's legal to turn my DD around. But there are studies out there that say it's not the safest alternative to have her FF before 2. If I did turn her around legally and had an accident where she broke her neck, could I live with the knowledge that I KNEW it was safer to keep her RF? I would have a VERY hard time with that.

But, as it has been stated before, people can do whatever they are comfortable with.
Print Post      Close Window