Re: immunizations/vaccines - thoughts??
Posted 3/11/2011 5:43:41 PM by OrganicMama


Posted by bicosi


Posted by OrganicMama


Posted by Karen


Posted by OrganicMama


Posted by jlk51496


Posted by OrganicMama

If you're considering delaying or not vaccinating at all, I think there are some things you need to take into consideration.

Is your DC breastfed? That offers some protection, but not everything that a vaccine would.

Will your DC be going to daycare?

Do you plan on taking any mommy & me classes, Gymboree, etc?

I have chosen to not start vaccinating DS until he is at least 15 months old (he's 9 months now). He is BF (and that is and will be his main source of nutrition until at least a year, he gets at least 90% breastmilk, only about 10% table food or less). He is not in daycare, and I will not bring him to any type of play places or mommy & me classes until he gets his vaccines. I'm limiting our activities, but by doing that I'm also limiting his exposure.

Also, by waiting until DS is 15 months I am able to cut the number of vaccines that he gets down to 12 (versus the 36 or 37 recommended by the AAP). I can FM you my schedule if you would like.

I highly recommend reading Dr. Sears book on vaccines.



Please dont take this the wrong way....but where DO you take your child!

Do you not even take them to mall? family parties? any store?

At 15 months my kiddies had done so many things, seen so much and had such wonderful experiences! I couldn't imagining keeping my children that sheltered for that long! I would go insane myself. I cannot wait for the nice weather to do all these things again this Spring/summer!

I don't question your decision not to vaccinate, just is it all worth it/necessary?




I take him pretty much everywhere I go - the mall, grocery store, target, parks, parties, airplane, etc. The only places I WON'T bring him to are indoor play places, because there are SO MANY kids and SO MANY germs. When I bring him to the mall or grocery store, he's not touching everything that a thousand other kids have touched and then putting his hands in his mouth. I either put him in a sling or use a shopping cart cover. I'm by no means a germaphobe, but I'm not someone that wants her kids sucking on the handle of the shopping cart either.

I have a playgroup that I meet with every week, and it's the same kids every week.

So yes, for ME, it is worth it. I didn't go to Gymboree or Le Play Cafe or daycare when I was a baby, and neither did my siblings. We played outside, with friends, and at home. My mom took us everywhere. I don't think my kid not going to a Mommy & Me music class is the end of the world and he'll be scarred for life. JMO.



I'm sorry, but I am not understanding your logic. You won't take him to indoor playplaces because of germs, but you take him to the mall and the airport and things of that nature? Isn't he more likely to develop a serious illness from places like the mall and airport where you are exposed to a LOT more people that are probably not vaccinated?

The worst thing my children have ever gotten from an indoor playplace was a bad head cold. Haven't the most recent outbreak of things like measles and whooping cough been traced back to the mall and the airport?




First of all, I BF, so there he does have a level of protection.

Like I said before, when we go to the mall, Target, the grocery store, etc, he's not touching things. I put him in the sling or the stroller, and if he's in a shopping cart I used the shopping cart cover. At an indoor play place, he would be crawling everywhere, touching things that a ton of other kids touched (who may or may not be vaccinated), putting things in his mouth that other kids had in their mouths, etc. He's not doing that when I bring him out because I DON'T LET HIM. Also, other people aren't touching him, breathing on him or coughing/sneezing in his face.

Just because a kid is vaccinated against Pertussis or a lot of other diseases doesn't mean they won't get it. Both my DH and I got the Dtap vaccine immediately after DS was born to further protect him. That was the disease I was most concerned about. And yes, to my knowledge the last case of measles was traced back to the airport. An airplane is not the best place to bring an unvaccinated child, but again, I BF so he has some protection. But the MMR isn't given until a year anyways!!! So are you telling me that NO ONE else on this board has brought their infant on an airplane before they've gotten the MMR vaccine?




I totally respect your stance.

I don't recall breastfeeding being a substitute for vaccinations.

In your other thread, you mentioned your child is sick.. and yet you tried all you did above and even that didn't stop him from getting a cold. kwim? disease is no different.

Even you or I can pass it along to our children... not due to being ill but by doing something as innocent as grabbing a box of cereal off the shelf.. who knows? maybe someone with the flu or with a cold or with some sort of illness coughed into their hand or wiped their nose and then went to grab that same box and then opted for a different brand.. you go and grab it innocently and throw it in your cart and right there you're taking it home with you.

When I flew with my kids when they were infants, they had had a number of vaccines by that point.. Hep B, Dtap, HIB, Pcv and that pollovirus one...and even still, there is always a risk of getting something.. not just them but even us as adults...

I'm sure I'm babbling at this point but all I'm saying is that things aren't the same as they were when we were kids... Some of the diseases out there are scary..




You're right, BFing isn't a substitute for vaccinations (I never said it was). I said that it "offers some protection, but not everything that a vaccine would".

I've made an informed decision, and I know the risks. I'm doing what I feel is best for my family.

And just to be clear, there are risks with everything, vaccines included.
Print Post      Close Window