Re: Libya anyone?
Posted 2/24/2011 9:23:18 PM by mbg1007
Posted by BunnyWife
Posted by mbg1007
Posted by LoriH
Posted by Bxgell2
Posted by KartveliT
Posted by apples99
Posted by Ophelia
Posted by Bxgell2
I know it's selfish, but my greatest fear right now is for Israel with all the instability surrounding it. Many, of not most of the leaders of the surrounding countries were questionable dictators, but they at least maintained fairly reasonable relations with Israel. God knows what's going to start filtering through now that there isn't any order
I can understand that on a personal, but I think that Israel should not be the go to focus of this. I honestly think it's insulting to the people that are actually involved in these uprisings especially since thus far, all countries have assured they will uphold treaties.
ITA Israel is fine.. if anything, for the Western world to pour in funds, they have to play nice with Israel.
And these people are fighting for basic needs for themselves and their family.. Israel is far, far, far from their minds.
agree.
Really, fine? I don't think so, when I hear from my own family just a few weeks ago who have lost a relative from a rocket. It was only a few short years ago that Libyans captured, and killed, several young Israeli men serving in the Army on the border.
OF COURSE I have sympathies and concern for all those involved in the uprisings, but for me, knowing the general instability in the area, not just in Libya, but most of the surrounding countries, I have immediate concerns for my own family in a neighboring country, which is surrounded by countries with a history of terrorist attacks.
While I agree that the surrounding countries are going to be impacted and understand the concern for your family, continuing to make this about Isreal is really not right. Maybe start a seperate thread about how the situation is impacting the surrounding area and the concern for your family.
How did she continue to make this post about israel? She responded to a general post about libya with her concerns about the effects of the situation, her VERY valid concerns. To truly understand the politics of that region is to understand the concern for israel, the only democratic country in that region. I'm very, very concerned too and I don't think that takes away from the suffering of the people in libya at all, one is not dependent on the other.
Having a valid concern I understand. I really do, but let's be honest for a second. These people in Libya, Egypt, and Tunisia want the same things that Israel has. A democratically elected government. They want to end the tyranny and human right violations they have been subjected to for years.
Israel has a lot of it's own problems too and that shouldn't be forgotten either.
I wasnt making a statement or conclusion at all about Israel's problems or whether the people in these countries want democracy, my point was that Israel's safety now with all the civil wars going on in that region is a valid concern and it is obviously a concern of hers and I just didnt think it was right to tell her that she was taking something away from the issue and should start her own post, I mean she was responding to a general question after all, jmo.
|