Re: Tax Cap
Posted 2/19/2011 9:15:54 AM by bookworm


Posted by ChrisDee

I am not sure why people do not understand this concept. YOUR school will still be YOUR school. YOUR neighborhood will go to YOUR local school. What is the issue?



the issue is that all the property tax money would go into one pot, and the district (under the pressure to address passing rates on state tests) can dole it out disproportionately to pad underperforming schools that they're now responsible for. it's not that different from your state taxes--long island pays out a lot more than it gets back in funding because we're "rich" and can afford to pay for everyone else apparently. a lot of our money goes upstate.

if similar districts combine, that's one thing. but you won't see excellent school districts combining with poor ones.


Posted by SlurpeeDad


Posted by bookworm

* as a teacher in a district that is very diverse and serves students from all walks of life, rich and poor, i'll tell you why people don't want to combine districts. because of testing, all of the focus is on kids who can't demonstrate basic math and literacy skills on grade-level. those are the kids who get the schools "in trouble" with the state. therefore, it's constantly being drilled into me to differentiate. translation: give the kids who are doing okay something they can handle on their own so you can provide one-on-one attention to the kid in the front row because he's reading 3 years below grade-level and has to pass the test. it just comes down to the fact that most of the energy and payroll in a district like mine goes toward dealing with problem kids--problem kids who get this way because some azzhole had a baby but didn't feel like being a parent. i'm sorry, as a teacher, i serve all my students as best i can despite their situation, and my heart goes out to kids whose parents are pieces of garbage who don't do the right thing; but as a teacher, i also know how it goes. when it comes to my own kids, i don't want to share. that's why i live where i live.



I understand that not all kids have the best parents, but when is the teacher held responsible for a child not learning on a level on par with their grade? My sister is guilty of saying the same things. She takes credit for when a student does awesome, but puts the blame on a parent when the student fails.



well, i've seen tenured teachers ousted for poor performance, so it does happen. it happens when administration is vigilant, and if they really do their jobs, those teachers don't get tenure in the first place.

i can also acknowledge that the strides my more successful students make are a combined effort made by me and their parents. i don't take full credit, but i do take some when i see a kid's writing transform over the course of the school year, though i well know it wouldn't have happened without the follow-up at home. i'm always grateful to a conscientious parent.

but those severe deficits in reading cannot exclusively fall on the shoulders of teachers. learning to read is thousands of hours of commitment OUTSIDE OF SCHOOL with parents who take kids to the library to get them excited about books, read to them when they're little and pressure kids to DO HOMEWORK. it can't happen in an hour a day (or less). i love the idea that i am held responsible for a 7th grader's inability to pass a grade-level literacy test in may when he came to me in september reading on a 2nd grade level because he spent the first 3 years on his life crying alone in a playpen while his mother was giving BJs for crack. this is real. even if he makes strides with me and leaves reading on a 4th grade level, we as a school have still failed. it's ridiculous.

if a patient goes to the doctor and is diagnosed with diabetes but then neglects to take the prescribed insulin or monitor blood sugar and dies, do you blame the doctor? schools can only do so much in the absence of parenting.
Print Post      Close Window