Re: Help with an offer pls . . .
Posted 2/14/2011 1:07:24 PM by Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties

You said you looked at comps from the "area." Are you looking at comps from same style homes in the same school district and neighborhood? That's important for the comps to be truly comparable. Also, the more recent, the better. It's best to look back 3 to 4 months only, if possible.

Keep in mind when looking at comps that things like a garage, finished basement, lot size, central air, upgrades to kitchens, baths, roofs, heating systems, etc. all add value.

It's hard to know whether a seller will consider a lower offer, because it all depends on the seller's motivation. Do they NEED to sell, or are they just testing the market to see if they can get a certain price? Also, a seller's response to an offer is often influenced by how long the home's been on the market, how much activity there's been, etc. Unfortunately, a buyer usually isn't privy to such information before making an offer.

When responding to an offer, a seller may accept it, counter it, or just reject it outright. If a seller rejects your offer, you can always come back with a higher bid, but sometimes a seller won't entertain another offer from a buyer who has come in too low the first time (because they are insulted, etc.). So there's always a risk of that when you make a low offer.

A good agent can often help get an offer accepted by highlighting other desirable characteristics of a buyer (financial qualifications, ability to close quickly, etc.) and make an emotional appeal to the seller as well (point out that the buyer loves the home, wants to raise a family there, etc.). But there has to be SOME rationale for the price you offer. It helps to have good comps to back it up.

How did you get to the $375K number? Is it completely arbitrary. Whether you are working with or without an agent, someone is going to have to justify why you are coming in so low. It sounds like your only complaint is that the painting and some cosmetic work was done imperfectly, but that is not going to justify coming in $60K under asking, in my opinion.

If it's an affordability issue, then I'd say go ahead and offer that price and see if you get lucky. But if you can afford more, and you really want the house and think it's worth the asking price, then I'd say to make the best offer you can afford. And by the way, I don't think "worth the asking price" is always a matter of looking at comps and determining fair market value. An overpriced home may be worth it to you personally, because of factors such as location, features and benefits, etc. If you plan to stay long-term and are not concerned about resale value in the near future, sometimes fmv is less of an issue, you know?

Hope this helps!

Lots of luck,
Christine
Print Post      Close Window