Re: Convertible Carseat
Posted 2/2/2011 8:42:12 PM by tara73

Please don't refer to Consumer Reports for car seat safety ratings. For ease of use? Yes. Safety? No.

While I personally love CR for many things, car seats isn't one of the things I would go to them for. They've had to retract "studies" after performing the tests wrong and in one case blatantly ignored the instructions on how to install and use the seat.

Here's a great response by a tech regarding the tests and the issues
http://www.car-seat.org/showthread.php?t=153305&highlight=consumer+reports

All seats sold on the US market today pass the same federal testing. Used correctly, they're all just as safe.

I'd personally choose a nicer seat than the Scenera.. It is a very no frills seat, and while that doesn't affect safety it does affect comfort and ease of use. Also, both of those seat only go to 50lbs and RF to 35. The Triumph 65 is a better option than the Advance if you like the Triumph.

Please consider looking at some other seats, specifically ones with side impact protection such as the Graco MyRide 65, TrueFit, Complete Air, Marathon etc. And actually go to the store and touch them. Try them in your car, with your kid. Get the one that is easiest to use and install that fits your budget, your vehicle and your kid.

Print Post      Close Window