Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off
Posted 1/25/2011 10:51:58 AM by labonnevie
Posted by BlackJack96
I may have missed a post so I apologize if this was covered. I think some of you are mixing up a "first time" chicken pox infection as an adult with shingles which is reactivation chicken pox.
Here are the facts:
1. Unless you have had a prior chicken pox infection you cannot get shingles which is typically a "band" of painful blisters on the skin. So folks with natural immunity from having had chicken pox can get shingles. It is in theory possible to get shingles from the vaccine since it's live, but that is rare.
2. "first time" chicken pox infection is worse in adults than in kids. The antivax folks are concerned I guess that if the immunity wears off and you get chicken pox as an adult you can get really sick.
3. The vaccine is effective in most but some 10-20 percent the immunity wears off. If the vaccine immunity wears off you can get a primary chicken pox infection all over your body (not shingles although some people mix the 2 up).
I guess parents are taking one of 3 options:
1. Not giving: Here you have a risk of getting chicken pox now (or later) and while may get the disease you could have a severe case.
2. Not giving and going to the pox party: Here you are more likely to get the disease and more likely to get a milder case (if younger), but there's a chance you may not and then later on get a severe case.
3. Giving the vaccine (my opinion, and that of the CDC, AAP, etc, etc, the BEST and really ONLY choice): You have a good shot at lifelong immunity and low risk of singles. If your immunity does wane off by the time it does assuming vaccination rates are high the risk of getting the disease is extremely low since we've killed the reservoir by vaccinating everyone. Also, the risks from the vaccine are less than the risks of getting the disease.
thank you for your clarification!
|