Re: Question about holding back for kindergarten- sorry- long
Posted 1/21/2011 2:33:45 AM by itsbabytime


Posted by Goobster


Posted by MrsGmomof3

Personally, I would hold him back. He will be in a classroom with children who are turning 6 the following week. There is a HUMONGOUS difference between a 4 year old and a 6 year old. HUGE.

I am a firm believer that NYS needs to change the cut offs across the board, make it a statewide thing, not a district thing, and that it should be September 1. As a former teacher, I firmly feel that each child walking into a kindergarten classroom should already be 5 years old. My oldest is a Sept. baby, and had he been born in October or later, he would have been held back.

However, its your decision, you know your child best.



Wow. I never knew there was such a trend to hold back.

I really didn't know people had a choice on the matter. I didn't realize you can hold back your DC voluntarily. But by doing so it really creates a much larger gap in the classroom setting, what was less than one year for your DC is now 1.5 years over another child. That doesn't seem right to me.

No flames please. Just my thoughts. I think if the school system is going to allow this, they should come up with a different cutoff date to even things out better so people dont keep holding their kids back, further widening the age differences in a class.




There is a HUGE trend now. My DS is born the end of Aug. and I have heard repeatedly that he will be one of the youngest in his class b/c of this. Not only is it a trend but, in some of the more affluent areas there is a ton of peer pressure to do so. Especially for boys. The parents are all convinced that the boys need to be bigger and more mature to be better in sports and therefore more successful in life Chat Icon I am NOT kidding. Also, for the girls, maturity wise I have heard of girls being picked on b/c they were so much younger and less mature than the others in their class. There is a HUGE difference IMO b/w a child over a year older at that age. Their attention span is much shorter often and leads to teachers thinking there is a problem when sometimes it is just maturity.

Personally, I don't agree with. I am an end of year baby and always was at the top of my class every step of the way. I was very against this when I first heard of it. Luckily, I don't have a child near the cut-off b/c now I am actually unsure of what I would do.

But, to the OP - if your teachers are telling you to put him in K - I would. From what I hear the teachers are often on the opp end so, they must be confident your DS will be a-okChat Icon
Print Post      Close Window