Re: Question about holding back for kindergarten- sorry- long
Posted 1/20/2011 3:40:26 PM by Goobster
Posted by EtWaFM
First off, I am a December birthday, started school at age 4, and was top of my class, very successful in school. Like a previous poster, I was shy, but this would have persisted if I was the oldest, too. My brother, who has a November birthday, was very outgoing, so I think it is more personality than birthday.
I understand your concerns about adolescence- but I'm not sure how holding him back or not will influence it either way. Some kids hit puberty at age 9, some at 14, it doesn't matter what grade they are in. If he is in puberty later than his peers, if anything that will probably protect him from STDs, if you know what I mean. If he is younger than his peers, he will have more time in high school not driving, depending on parents and friends for rides, and you will have more control over knowing his whereabouts. If he is one of the oldest, that may make him less susceptible to peer pressure as you presume, or it may make him one of the risk takers because he is with younger kids. My point is, you just don't know what is going to happen in the teenage years, but I think it has more to do with personality than being the oldest/youngest in the grade.
Wow. You bring up such excellent points and I think you hit the nail on the head!
In addition, when I was growing up, whenever a child in our class was "older" than the rest, we automatically knew the child was held back (not by choice).
So for me, if I voluntarily held my DC back, I would be concerned that some people might assume (when learning my child's age) that they were "involuntarily" held back. I know it's more common now but could a child voluntarily held back be stigmatized as a child involuntarily held back? KWIM? Just another thought.
|