Re: Question about holding back for kindergarten- sorry- long
Posted 1/20/2011 1:59:15 PM by Salason


Posted by stickydust

I think you and I have already discussed this but I am 95% sure I am holding C back a year. Reason being that she would not make the cut-off in any other district. Like M, she is very bright- know which words rhyme, can write her name etc when I compare her to kids whose birthday is the previous January I feel that she is not on par with maturity.

Another mom also made a good point to me. In the rest of the U.S. the cut-off is usually Sept 1 or something which means parents are holding their August kids back a year (I even know a late July b-day who is being held back a year in MA). When she gets to college, because of this trend C can easily be like 1.5 years younger than many kids. I know its a long way off but I do think about the social impact of being the youngest by such a large margin.



I've been thinking about this as well. DS is 10/18 and we had never intended to hold him back bc he's academically advanced (per his teachers). DH is also an 11/29 bday and is adamant that it never affected him negatively. But his cousin is 2 mos older than him (August) and their cutoff is 9/1 so SIL is holding her back. And his other cousin is 14 mos older than him (also August, also held back with the 9/1 cutoff) will be in DS' grade. Seems so bizarre to me and it's starting to sway me because while DS is very bright, I dont think he's nearly as socially mature as either of these cousins and his peers in general and I'm afraid of how that will impact him.

I wish I had advice but I'm struggling with the same issue Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window