Re: Interesting Event-Discuss
Posted 1/17/2011 1:53:57 PM by IrishLasss334


Posted by MissRadiant


Posted by IrishLass


Posted by MissRadiant


Posted by IrishLass

I wrote too much and got timed out. Yes,actually you did miss something. At some point in time in the existance of this country there has been discrimination of every ethnicity that showed up on the shores. And there was something called "indentured servants" - where people of many races came to this country and it wasn't called slavery, but that's exactly what it was, and they were sold as well, except it wasn't called "selling", because after 1868 that was against the law. Their "contracts" for work were sold and the "servants" has to "work off" their passage here. They can change the names all they like, it's a form of slavery. It happened to my family in the late 1800's, early 1900's, 1940's and my FIL in 1956. It still goes on today, containers of illegal immigrants working as prostitutes, selling drugs, maids, even in nail salons doing your nails, landscapers...denied the "basic rights of humanity" as you say.

Forget all that - we can debate that until the cows come home.

When do we start becoming Americans and unify as a country as Americans? This is really what my whole point is. Yes, celebrate and be proud of our heritages, but I think there are things out there and keep us from becoming unified and keep us emphasizing our diversity, not always a bad thing, but it keeps us from coming together. The only real time I can remember that everyone said they were an AMERICAN, and not an Italian American, Irish American, Spanish American, African American was after 9/11. We were all JUST AMERICANS and proud to stand together as one. It lasted for awhile. It would be nice if it didn't have to be a national disaster that made us all feel that way.




Really?????...You just minimized slavery and compared it to indentured servants. I don't get it, maybe I am the only one that sees someone paying for a debt through work-then moving on with their lives as something totally different then being taken from their homeland, chained, beaten and not fed to be sold as an item, not be considered a human being, having NO rights and being tortured without seeing an end to a "contract".
Was being an indentured servant horrible -yes it was and I will not take away from that, but they also did have it better then many others which had no rights whatsoever.



I absolutely did not minimize it. If you read my comment about what goes on today, with the so called "indentured servants" - who come here in containers from all different countries, who end up as prostitutes, sex slaves, under the guise of being nannies, maids, etc. Living that life is just as bad, if you ask me, than being a slave in 1864.

And, did your family come here like that? Mine did. We have letters of what it was like. I can tell you because it was my family, they came here as a family AFTER 1868. They were supposed to live together and work on a farm in Kirkland, NY. Instead, they were split up sent to separate farms and worked under horrific circumstances, not allowed to leave the farm they worked, they had no rights, couldn't vote. Oh yeah, they were fed - bread and water, grizzle from meat, enough to keep them well enough to work the farms. They lived like that for 10 years. Maybe it was only 10 years, but it was a hellish 10 years after slavery was allegedly abolished.

It's just a different name.



I am not saying that the experience that your family had was not horrible- it was. But it was 10 years compared to people which spent their whole lives as slaves. Born to slave parents as slaves, died as slaves and their children were slaves. Yes even after "slavery ended" they were still not treated as the Americans that they were. Indentured servants also had the opportunity to "buy out" their contracts in less time.
We can go back on this for hours, but honestly if that's how you feel lets just agree to disagree and get back to the OP's intent with this topic.
*Irony* Having this conversation on MLK day.



I'm sorry to continue this after you agreed to disagree, but how do you expect indentured servants to "buy out" their contracts in less time when they were earning no money and were working just to pay it off? How that's done now is by "selling" one of your kids into the sex slave business, and if you don't think it happens, it does. Is that not as bad?

Yes, we can agree to disagree. It's just that there are all degrees of everything and my whole other point about unification and having a feeling of unity was totally ignored, which is part of the irony of having the conversation today.
Print Post      Close Window