Re: anyone else get upset over their house losing value
Posted 11/19/2010 8:02:38 PM by ave1024


Posted by KellyFG


Here's the way I look at short term ( 5 year) real estate "losses"-
you bought a house, paid whatever you & you lender agreed it was worth during the height of the recent market, most homeowners get some tax advantages yearly, you probably would have paid at least $2k per month to rent something even close to the size/location/comfort level of your house and the value today really doesn't mean anything unless you are trying to sell or refinance.
So if you take away to money you would have paid as rent, the tax savings you got and the value of the memories your family made in YOUR home...its probably not as severe as it seemed at first.





I'll agree that it may not be as big of a deal if you aren't refinancing or selling. And real estate is long term. But I definitely disagree with the bolded point.

Typically I have found that when you add mortgage taxes PLUS real estate taxes, you typically are paying more than what you would pay for a comparable rental (as you described).

If your house dropped 50k, that is pretty severe no matter how the person wants to spin it! You just lost 50k from your portfolio. Especially when you already paid a ton of those taxes and interest. So as far as being in a 2k rental, you are basically breaking even... WITHOUT losing 50k of net worth.

Tax advantages of owning don't outweigh the loss of net worth when your house declines in value drastically.

Many people really over-estimate home ownership tax advantages. Remember the golden rule: in order to get tax savings, you need to first PAY TAXES.
Print Post      Close Window