Re: FDA Issues Consumer Safety Alert: Hylands Teething Tablets
Posted 10/29/2010 4:41:35 PM by Xelindrya


Posted by mommyIam

IMO, the reasoning is bogus. The amount is inconsistent because the amount is negligible to nothing. The methods to dilute it, dilute to such a low amount that instruments can't detect it.

DH (a physican) was very concerned about the belladonna, he and our Ped discussed it at depth. Our ped had to explain what homeopathic means to DH. Its not something taught in med school, or in college probably. Anyway our ped said the only real ingredient in it is lactose.

With that said, and my personal feelings are that the product got too popular and the company that makes Orajel probably lobbied for it to be recalled, I probably will be hesitant about using it, just cause I have some faith the FDA isn't a bunch of puppet monkeys.

eta: we looked into it, the gel, is not recalled, has the same ingredients.

FDA says the methods are producing inconsistent batches.

The company hasn't had a recall or report of any problem in its over 100 years of existence.



ITA!

Its yet another scare tactic. Inconsistant is a Ridiculously vague description. Its not pure belladonna. And how many tablets are you giving the kid?

AJ used them sucessfully but never more than twice in a day for the limited 2-3 tablets.

This certainly wouldn't stop me from buying them.

#1 its an FDA alert
#2 they voluntarily recalled it (without being told unlike others lately)
#3 anything in great qualities is dangerous
#4 every drug FDA approved or not will have adverse reactions in a % of people with or without large quanities.


Chat Icon

I tried them myself before I gave them to AJ there's just no way you can convince me of that itty bitty tiny amount in the correctly suggested dosage under controlled circumstance is the equilivant to bug parts in a child's formula or faulty tylenol.

But to each their own.

If AJ ever needs them again and I decided to give her a lot in a single day I'll know that the belladonna probably played a part.

On a side note, aren't we always reading the labels... why would anyone be surprised that belladonna is in it?
Print Post      Close Window