Re: If someone asks your nationality
Posted 10/16/2010 9:35:24 PM by LoveBeingMrsT


Posted by Jax430


Posted by Cacarina


Posted by Andrewz00


Posted by PreshusSmurf

Jewish or American, depending on the context of the conversation.




hmmm.. i never quite figured that one out... like Jewish from Judea?

why is it that Jewish people always say Jewish? should i have been saying all along "Im Catholic" ?


Nationality: American
Ethnicity: Italian and German



LOL - I always wonder that too. Jewish is not a nationality or an ethnicity. But almost all my Jewish friends say this as their ethnicity.



My nationality is American.
My ethnicity is Jewish, and no one can tell me otherwise.


The reason that Jewish people typically identify their ethnicity as Jewish rather than their country of origin is that Jews were never accepted or assimilated into those countries. They were persecuted in every country where they lived, and their carried their Jewish traditions with them from location to location.

My family is from Romania, Poland, and Russia, but they did not bring the traditions and customs of those countries with them when they immigrated to America, they brought JEWISH food, music, and language (Yiddish). These things transcend geographical boarders.

Yes, Judaism is a religion, but it is also a culture and an ethnicity, and many people identify much more strongly as cultural Jews than religious Jews.



exactly!

i say jewish 1st then american. my family came from hungary.
Print Post      Close Window