Re: Would you be upset if...
Posted 10/10/2010 4:38:45 PM by browneyedgirl


Posted by WhatNow

My honest answer, yes! I would be upset and very uncomfortable with that! I don't think it would be fair to either group. It would keep the kids developing at regular pace behind and not let them go forward in their studies with the speed they are able to, and it would also not let the special needs children have the extra attention and particular environment they require.



this is a misperception of what an inclusion class is. it will NOT, by any means, keep typial kids from developing at a regular pace. in fact, it is proven to do the opposite. typical kids get the attention of at least 2 adults full time. the teachers have more resources and time to create differentiated lessons and more challenging activities for higher level kids.

there is nothing that would stop the special needs kids from having extra attention!!!! they have a full time special ed teacher, and a full time general ed teacher, who can modify and tailor lessons to their individual style of learning. they blossom in these programs (if they are appropriately placed).

it's a win win for everyone. as an inclusion teacher for 7 years (and teaching for 10) and as a mom of 2 kids, it honestly upsets me that people think being in an inclusion kid would be detrimental to their child. ALL kids have strengths and weaknesses. there are children with learning and behavioral disabilities in ALL classes. being learning disabled (or any type of disabled) DOES NOT equal having behavior problems!!!! it is 2 completely different things. of course kids with learning problems can have behavioral issues, but so can typically developing children!

typical kids learn so much from being placed with children who have learning needs. they are NOT there to "teach" those kids. they all learn together, at their own pace, and they thrive. the most well rounded typical children come out of an inclusion class because they have learned patience, compassion and love from working with all different kinds of kids. they also get extra attention because they have 2 teachers!!! most general ed classes (which ALWAYS have unidentified struggling learners) have 24 kids with one teacher. most inclusion classes are typically slightly smaller and have 2 teachers. so an inclusion class with 22 kids and 2 teachers (at least) has an 11 to 1 ratio as opposed to a 24 to 1 ratio.
my class right now has a 6 to 1 ratio because we have a full time student teacher--you can't beat that level of personalized instruction!!!

please feel free to ask me any questions regarding this model. i consider myself to be an expert as i have been well trained and have significant experience. seeing this poll is disheartening because many parents are uninformed of what this class truly is.

i will be requesting inclusion for my 2 kids every year if it is available. i know they will thrive if they are placed there whether they are an identified kid, typical learner, or advanced learner.

of course every teacher and every class is different, but there is NOTHING to be scared of if your child is placed in this setting. you are more likely to meet with behavior problems in typical classes because children with behavior problems (who don't have identified learning problems) are usually kept out of these classes.

please don't judge a model if you're not informed about it. you are doing your child a disservice by thinking your child is "above" it.
Print Post      Close Window