|
House extension... need some help sort it out! LONG
Posted 9/17/2010 2:36:53 PM by smdl We have a levitt house. The ranch (the one that you come into the kitchen. Not the door in the middle of the house). Kitchen is small. 12x13 or 14. LR is small 12x16. We had someone come for an estimate. Here are the issues or why we need an extention. 1/ we don't have a dining area. So we are cramped in a 12x13 room to eat. Needless to say. DS does not eat at the same time we do. We don't fit in it. 2/ We have to redo ALL the windows (we still have all the original aluminum sliders) as well as new siding (it has started to come apart and rotting) and new roof. It leaks in the garage. 3/ We can't have more than 8 guests in our house at one time. The LR is just too small. Now, let's talk $$$ The windows, siding and roof will cost $18K. I think it's fair. Isn't it? All the windows with 2 bedrooms upstairs (minus 2 windows in the bathrooms. we just redid them). We have to do it, just to prevent further damage in the house and I am tired of no energy drafty windows too. I can't have a leaky room either. I would love to insulate the garage but I can't do that if the rook leaks. We could expend the kitchen by 6-8 feet in the front yard. Cost: approx $18K (includes labor w/o materials to retile the whole kitchen and tile that goes all the way in the hallway (same tile!)). We live in township of Oyster Bay. We will need a variance. It would take right now 6-9 months. Extension in the back. 12x20. Approx. $31K. If we did the extension in the back, we would have an open DR where our LR is and push the LR furniture to the back/extension. The whole thing together would come to $67K. DH and I are on board with the siding/windows/roof and back extension. Essentially I don't really need the kitchen extension on the front. I would just have a small kitchen but not an eating kitchen so it would be functional. BUT.....I think our house has NO curb appeal. It's a levitt ranch house and let's just say that they are not that pretty. We don't have the A line roof either. The "flat" style. So an extension of the kitchen would look really nice. To top that now my kitchen would be really great. A 13 x 18 or 20 room. I have a make shift pantry in one of the few closets at the end of the hallway and a huge kitchen would provide me with LOTS of cabinet (right now it's an L shape 10 x10)... yes. That small!! No storage. The problems: 1/ It's $67K (we would need a loan) vs $50K (we don't need a loan) if we don't do the kitchen. $67K does not include redoing the kitchen cabinets. 2/ I could not redo the kitchen if I do both extensions to the front and back ($$$$) so I would not only have 1 wall of cabinets since I would have to rip the counter under the window. That wall would be gone due to the extension. And live with an extension for a while and no new cabinets and just a small 10 ft wall of cabinets. 3/ We think we could do the siding, etc... and the back extension NOW and wait 3 years to the kitchen extension. But we are worried that the 3 yo roof would look faded when we do the new roof of the kitchen extension. 4/Even if we did not do the kitchen extension I would not love the front of the house. Is curb appeal and a larger kitchen worth an additional $18K? Knowing we no longer have an issue with the eating situation with the back extension so the problem would be solved with the back extension. Decisions... decisions WWYD? |