Re: Carseat question
Posted 8/31/2010 8:41:54 AM by tara73

Ideally, yes, the safest place is the middle but that has been the case since well before airbags. It has to do mainly with side impacts, as another poster mentioned, and crash forces. Rear facing inherently allows for greater protection in side impact collisions than forward facing and being in the middle allows for crash forces to be lessened before reaching that passenger.

Not all cars can have a seat in the middle for a variety of reasons, hump in the middle, folding armrest etc. No LATCH in the center position does not mean you can not put a car seat in the middle, it's usually other factors (ie folding armrest) that make it problematic. ALL car seats sold on the market today must have the ability to be installed by either a seat belt OR lower anchors (and no, seat belts are not less or more safe than LATCH)

From Safercar.gov (NHTSA site) regarding the safety of Side Air Bags (SAB)


Potential Risk Side-Impact Air Bags (SABs)

To minimize the potential risk of SAB-related injuries to occupants - especially children - a group of automotive and insurance industry experts known as the Technical Working Group (TWG) developed voluntary SAB standards and testing procedures. Manufacturers now report to the government if the SABs in a given vehicle model have met the voluntary standards.

To find out if your vehicle's SABs meet the TWG standards, visit and search the vehicle database by make, model, and year. Vehicles reported as meeting the TWG voluntary standards will indicate "Meets Specification" beside the "SAB Out Of Position Testing" entry under "Air Bags." These out of position testing standards were developed primarily with children in mind. TWG standards information can also be found in the annual NHTSA "Buying a Safer Car" brochures. Prior to the development of the recommended TWG standards, many chest (torso) and head/chest combination (combo) SABs showed a potential for serious or fatal injury to children seated too close to a deploying air bag. However, very few vehicles sold in the U.S. have these types of SABs in the rear seating positions.

NHTSA has not seen any indication that current roof-mounted head SABs pose a risk to children. Many roof-mounted SABs now extend rearward to include the second and even the third row seating positions. You can check your owner's manual or visit and search the vehicle database to learn whether your vehicle is equipped with SABs, and if so, what type.

As of 2008, NHTSA has investigated over 1,500 cases where SABs have deployed in crashes. Sixty of the cases have involved children (ages 13 and under). NHTSA crash investigators found no moderate or serious injuries to these children as a result of SAB deployments. NHTSA continues to closely monitor real-world SAB deployments involving both children and adults.



NHTSA Database - SAB

So, you're both right in a sense, but your brother is relying on older information. There were concerns many years ago when the side impact airbags first started being put in vehicles, but the majority of today's side curtain and impact airbags don't have any concern in regards to child seats.

In all cases, you need to read your vehicle's AND your child restraint's manuals for best position and SAB safety and if you have questions contact a CPST for clarification.

Sorry that got so long winded!
Print Post      Close Window