Re: Has Brooke ever....
Posted 8/12/2010 6:13:42 PM by MrsKS
Posted by ns1011
Posted by MrsRitaB
Posted by DavaDay
I'm sorry, I think what she does to emotionally vulnerable women is not very nice.
Us ttc'ers are desperate to believe it will happen soon. And for most of us, it will: on average it takes about 6 months to conceive. Brooke just plays the averages and takes your money. Actually, she's pretty bad at the averages: I just did the math in another thread and she's only "right" 27% of the time.
I know a lot of people are doing it just for fun, and that's cool, but I've seen a number of girls really believe in Brooke and get so upset when their month comes around and there's AF again.
ita - i did it for fun but than you start imagining it happening when she says you do
like for me she said sept/oct and i really think that i will automatically get pregnant than
I'm with you ladies on this. I would never condemn anyone who emails this Brooke, be it for fun or out of depseration, but I just don't see how it can be anything more of a hoax. I've seen some people base everything all around her predictions and it kills me that she can warp people's minds so much. I'm sure she is going to be right sometimes, but she is probably wrong more often than that. And she seems to have a very generic response that she uses over an over again, with a small modification here and there. And I'm curious - does she ask you how long you have been TTC? That might explain why some people get a prediction that includes a "vision" of meds and/or special help. It doesn't take a psychic to know that if you have been unsuccessfully TTC for 6 months are so - it's a fairly safe guess you might end up at an RE undergoing some sort of fertility treatment.
ITA with you both. I did pay and do it. And while I don't totally regret it... I do think it's crap for the most part. Of course she is going to be right some of the time... its not like she says it WILL happen on this month or day... she always gives a range. And then when she does speak about a possible "test" coming up... she said it could be a pregnancy test!! UUMMMMM I'm not rocket scientist but I'll bet ya that every single one of the preggers has a test coming up!!!!!!!!!!!!!! How else would they know they were pregnant???
I feel like she has the same handful of responses that she rotates between us. I also don't think she realizes we are all on the same board talking about the responses... which makes her that much less credible!!
If anyone wants to email and pay me... I can give ya some of my predictions!!! Anyone can guess a timeframe and be right only 27% of the time!
|