Re: WWYD post... about pool...Edited to include the question
Posted 7/21/2010 4:03:08 PM by mamabear


Posted by Kelly9904

I dont see the issue with it.

My MIL would never do that, but I do it all the time. I have done it with my nieces and nephews without asking when they were younger.

Honestly I think your reaction was probably not the best for your DC simply because DC was upset and now by your reaction DC might start to associate that as a BAD thing.

DS hates when I dunk him but its part of learning to swim IMO and I will continue to do it because I feel its important for him to be comfortable in the water.

I should add that my reaction might have alot to do with the fact that I taught swim lessons for many years.



While I agree that babies need to learn to swim, go under water, etc, there are different ways to go about learning that, and that choice is up to the parents. I think MIL crossed a line by taking action that can scare DC and also instill a fear of water. Ive been slowly teaching DD by getting her to blow bubbles and get closer and closer to going under with me watching her on her own. If someone now came along and dunked her completely under, scaring her and upsetting her, not only would I be mad because they needlessly upset her, but they could have now made her scared to start putting her face in slowly.
Print Post      Close Window