Re: Any wine experts or real wine lovers here?
Posted 7/20/2010 11:03:14 AM by Kara


Posted by KellyFG



These were recommended to me by a friend that loves wine but has different taste IMO than the hostess I described.




Well, what are the hostess's tastes? There are many "good" bottles of wine. That doesn't mean everyone who likes wine is going to like every good bottle.

I've had the fortune to drink several 100 point (essentially the highest of the highest rated wines in the world) while I was in Italy. I didn't like a few of them...

Still, any bottle of wine is a nice gift IMHO. If it's not my cup of tea, I will still try it and I'll have it to offer guests at parties, etc.

As for what you've listed, I haven't had either... but the 2002 Chateau Pichon-Longueville Baron Pauillac (a Bordeaux) should be a VERY nice wine. The 2005 vintage is amazing, but way more expensive. Bordeaux usually is best when aged well, so this is a wine they can enjoy now and can actually keep a little bit longer. (Contrary to popular belief, not all wines get better with age and older is not always better.)

I personally tend not to like Chardonnay, so I can't tell you much about the 2007 Pouilly-Fuisse Louis Jadot other than to tell you 2007 is about the year you'd want to be drinking now. Chardonnays don't keep for too many years, but this one will probably keep another year or two if they want to cellar it for a while.

Of these two, I prefer the bourdeaux. I think it's a better wine generally and it's something I'd rather drink. I'd go with the Bordeaux. You don't find too many wine enthusiasts who say "I hate Bordeaux" but you do find a select few who don't care for Chardonnay, even the good stuff. That said, I'm obviously biased b/c I tend to dislike Chardonnay. Still, I think I would probably like the one you posted... In fact, I might have to give it a try! Chat Icon (And in fairness, there probably are some people who would say they don't care for reds from Bordeaux... but I haven't met them!)

In all honesty, though, I don't think you can go wrong with either one. I would be surprised, however, if they are both the same price. I would think the Chardonnay would be less expensive -- so if that is a consideration, I would go with the chardonnay.

ETA - I am not an expert. Just a wine lover. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window