Re: Report Cards and Lost Books
Posted 6/25/2010 7:26:00 AM by rojerono


Posted by AngelaD1031


Posted by rojerono

I don't mind paying for a book or finding it. I do mind that they would hold his progress hostage if I didn't have the money or means to do so. I pay thousands of dollars in taxes, spend endless hours helping my kid with schoolwork, go to PTA meetings, school meetings, assemblies, buy gifts, etc.. and they are going to tell me I don't have the right to know how my child did in school? I don't think so.





I'm sorry, I hope you don't mind me butting in here but I'm a 7th grade teacher and I just wanted to respond from the school's perspective.

Could you imagine how much more you'd be paying in taxes if there were no penalties for losing a book? I have a list of at least twenty names of kids who have not returned their class library books. I think a lot more students and their parents would have a nonchalant attitude about returning things if they knew nothing would happen if they didn't. The schools would have to replace all of those books (you can't have students without text books!) and money would be eaten from the budget in that way.

Not meant to start any problems, I just wanted to show the other side of this.



No problems - I am not remotely upset or annoyed by the idea that most people do not agree with me! :) I actually DO get the perspective of the school and understand why they want/need to secure the money for lost books. I would never in a million years debate that.

Having said that - there needs to be a different way to secure those lost items. It seems absurd to withhold a progress report because of it. It's like "Sorry - you don't have the book so we aren't going to let you know what your child might need to work on this summer!" And what about teacher conferences? Would a teacher say "Yeah - sorry, I can't give you any of my time to discuss your child because they lost a library book and giving you insight into their progress is not allowed until they put up or pay up."

Again - my kid loses a book he's going to find it or he's going to pay for it. But the idea that they are going to hold his progress hostage REALLY sits wrong with me.

And I have to think Erica must be correct - if your child goes to a public state-funded school it seems within the parents inherent right to be given reports on progress. I think any parent who chose to 'fight' the school on the issue would win.

Print Post      Close Window