Re: Help settle a debate on whether most people tip mechanics! (poll)
Posted 6/12/2010 1:14:31 PM by MsMBV


Posted by smdl


Posted by CouponMom

I work in a different field that you would not normally tip. But when I do get a tip, I am sure to go out of my way to give them the best service possible (within the rules of what I am allowed to do). I don't give the non-tipper any less, but I do give the tipper more, KWIM?



Sorry but this is a bit unethical. I am in a tip industry and I can tell you that it would be very unprofessional, unethical and not allowed for the conduct of my profession to offer more to people who tip me.

A mechanic does not make what the shop charges. Of course not! But they are paid by the standard of their industry. They go by a book that tells them how to calculate time for each service performed. For example, you get 1/2 hour credit (or whatever the book says!) for an oil change. So now the shop is charging the customer for the 1/2 hour the book says. The mechanic gets paid the 1/2 hour x his hourly rate (negociated at time of employement. Depends on level of expertise, experience, etc..). A timing belt is about 4 hours credit. So now if a mechanic does it in 3. Client is still charged for 4. Mechanic is paid for 4 x his hourly rate. Mechanics do check all the jobs they do to make sure they get the credits they do. Trust me!

Some places pay more than others. Good mechanics make good money.

ITA with all of this except that last statement. Mechanics have ebbs and flows, just like all industries. During the downtimes, the mechanics get hit first, not the writers, or the finance managers, or the warranty advisors. So while overall, yes, a good mechanic is usually paid well, it is not as good as many think. Also, with the current economy, a lot of the classes that allow the mechanics to improve their skill set and poise themselves for promotions & raises are eliminated. And lastly, there have been 5% reductions in salary to prevent layoffs on many shops, and also they recently re-structured standard book hours for several manufacturers, and not in favor of the mechanics.

Not that it really matters, if you feel you should tip someone, then go for it.
Print Post      Close Window