|
Re: Thursdays QOTD
Posted 5/27/2010 3:33:07 PM by MrsDeVito DH and and I are completely on the same pafe as far as disciplining. We both agree that hitting/spanking isn't really effective, however if my 2 or 3 year old goes to run in the street after being told no, I will spank lightly. I DO want them to fear runningin the street and I just do not believe you can explain to a 2 or 3 year old the concept of getting hit by a truck and dieing, IMO at that age they do not have the maturity to understand something like that. I don't have my own experience to base this on, but I have seen it in practice with my niece. She is on eof the most well behaved children I have ever seen. She is 3 years old and since she could speak she has always said please and thank you, says excuse me instead of interupting adults, and has always been disicplined with time outs which BIL and SIL have been SO consistent with. I mean she has been taken to the corner of a restaurant for a time out. She also always has to apologize for what she did. Like when she was put in time out in the restaurant, when she came back to the table she had to say sorry to all of us for disrupting our dinner. With all that being said, she has still been spanked a handful of times for doing things that could cause harm to herself. She completely understands there being actions for consequences but at only 3 does not always get that certain things can hurt you. She got a light tap on the bottom once for trying to run into the street after being told numerous times it was dangerous, she could get hurt, she could get hit by a car. She didn't get it. If for now being afraid of getting a little spanking if she runs in the street keeps her from doing it I think it's ok. |