Re: American Idol 5/18
Posted 5/19/2010 7:36:05 PM by TaraHutch
Posted by rojerono
Kaaaaara and The Dawg picked "Daughters" for Casey. It was a little creepy.
Ellen chose "Baby I'm Amazed" for Crystal. I thought it was absolutely AWFUL.
Simon chose "Hallelujah" for Lee and they all lost their collective sh*t over his version. I did not love it like that... not even close. I thought it was merely okay.
Thank you. I so didn't get the reaction to his version. I felt it totally went against the whole point of the song. It started off nice...then the choir walked in, and then the band amped it up....felt so false to me. Wanted to love it, too.
|