Re: American Idol 5/18
Posted 5/19/2010 5:12:12 PM by Kara

Maybe it was my TV or something, but Crystal sounded completely and totally off key in both songs. I thought they were two boring, not-so-great performances from her. Then again, I really cannot stand her. I feel NOTHING when she sings and she appears to have no personality at all.

I am hoping for a Lee / Casey finale, but know that is a long shot.

Casey could have done better, but at least his voice sounded good. VERY odd song choices - both of them. I hated his version of Daughters. I think the judges made a terrible choice for him with that one.

Lee sounded amazing. This was the first night I was sort of wowed by him. Hallelujah is one of my favorite songs of all time. I cringed when I heard he was going to sing it because I generally hate covers of it -- I hated the Jason Whatshisface version of it from a past season. I thought Lee did a nice job with it, though. I thought Simple Man was a great song choice for him, too.

Interested to see who goes home tonight... I have a feeling it'll be Casey, though I really want it to be Crystal.
Print Post      Close Window