Re: Your Baby Can Read
Posted 5/14/2010 1:40:54 PM by MrsProfessor
Posted by Goldi0218
Posted by Porrruss
As a speech-language pathologist I can PROMISE you that talking and READING to your child is enough to stimulate language development. NO ONE needs a degree in early childhood language development to properly facilitate language development in their children. And no paid program is as good as personal one on one interactions with a caregiver.
Life experience and engaging activities that tap into visual, motor, and tactile (touch) skills are the best way for a child to make connections they'll need later for literacy skills, not being drilled with a bunch of pictures and words.
Play with playdoh and talk about what you are doing, how it feels, what it smells like, etc. Blowing bubbles and popping them while talking about the bubbles, counting the bubbles, describing the bubbles. All of these experiences teaches the words your child will need to know in order to later follow directions, make their own comments, ask their own questions, and later, remember these experiences while they learn to read in order to help with comprehension.
IRC correctly, those cards takes the teaching sight word recognition to a different level, which is NOT the best way for a child to learn to read overall. It's a way to learn to read more fluently, but not as efficient as phonemic awareness, which teaches decoding skills. The first level of learning literacy skills starts with phonemic awareness. The sight word stuff should come later.
Can you tell I'm not a fan?
Im with you 100%. I am not an SLP rather an educator and I am so turned off by this program it makes me nauseous. I was reading fluently at 3 and they didnt even have VCRs yet. Shoot they didn't even have cable yet.
Parents, READ to and with your kids. Describe EVERYHING and ANYTHING you do with your kids. Point to things and say what they are. Decoding means nothing if they have limited comprehension. bill Gates didn't have this and he turned out ok. sorry, I just cant stand the idea of programming a child with flashcards and videos as a baby. It makes me sad.
I agree with both of you. I am a teacher and I just see no value in this program (except for the people who created the program, who are making a killing.) I think reading to kids and talking about what they are reading (i.e. asking them how characters feel, what they think will happen next) has much more value.
I have seen plenty of kids who can decode very well, but can't retell, can't infer or predict, etc. These are skills that cannot be taught by a dvd.
|