Re: Your Baby Can Read?
Posted 5/12/2010 2:22:28 PM by mommyIam


Posted by MrsProfessor


Posted by Nshoregrl

Ok let me start by saying that I have never used this product...I have only seen the commercials on TV.

That being said, I work in early childhood education, and the method they use on the video doesn't really seem approriate for young children. When I say appropriate I mean as far as teaching methods. What it seems like to me is that you are teaching your child "sight" words. They recognize the visual of the word and then either say or act out the word (arms up) etc. This isn't really reading. Children need to learn all the letters of the alphabet first, learn what sounds they make and then string these sounds together to make words.

This product may work for some children I don't want to totally discredit it since I've never used it before. However, IMO it's not the best method to teach children to read.



I agree with you. I am a teacher, and I believe that learning and literacy begin at home- but there is no reason for a baby to read. There is a lot more value in reading to your child as early as possible, and building a love of books. It seems like there is a lot of decoding and memorization of sight words, which isn't really "reading".



I don't agree ... but this is only my opinion based on myself and DH:
I learned to read at age 4, my mother says by memorizing the words in the book, and I caught on to the phonics soon after and was always reading way beyond my grade level. DH says he did the same exact thing. DH continued to love books, he's read every classic in existence, I grew up to hate reading, to this day I still just skim books, I don't have patience to read them. So when our parents read to us at very young age, we didn't necessarily learn to love books, what we did do is learn to read by what you call "memorization of sight words".

I learned 2 other languages this way, was reading in 3 languages (that have different characters than English!) by age 6 at 1st grade level, and I still read those 2 on a 1st grade level Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window