Re: LOST 5/11
Posted 5/12/2010 8:22:40 AM by Teachergal


Posted by TheLorax

Maybe MIB as a child was not bad (actually I liked little-MIB better than little-Jacob), but once he became the smoke monster, he is evil. He is killing people left and right (Both as the smoke monster and through manipulation as Locke). On the island now, in past seasons, and throughout history (when Richard first came to the island, MIB wiped out the whole crew practically).

I thought this episode was actually making an analogy between Jacob:God & MIB:Lucifer. Jacob was saying how he thought people were innately good, and MIB said that was easy for Jacob to say since he was just watching from above (ie: God in Heaven). Perhaps MIB was good as a child, but when he became the smoke monster (and consumed with the notion of leaving the island), it was like Lucifer’s fall from heaven. MIB, like Lucifer, believes humans are innately evil. Lucifer was condemned to forever exist in hell, while MIB is similarly trapped on the island.

So while it may seem like Jacob is acting cruelly by drawing people to the island so they can prove they are good….couldn’t we say this island is simply a microcosm of what the traditionally believed in God does in the rest of the world? If you are good, you get into heaven. If not, you die and go to hell. God brought humans into existence and crappy stuff can happen to them (just like crappy stuff happens to the people on the island).



I totally see what you are saying here. And I agree with liking little-MIB more than little-Jacob. I think the creators want us to feel that way. It muddies the waters, so to speak.

I guess ultimately my thought is, if Jacob is bringing people to the island to test their humanity and only a few survive but the rest are traumatized (airplane survivors), driven to do bad things (Ben), or killed (most of the Black Rock people, the people in MIB's camp, most others on the island), is that really "good"? My real question is- Is killing in the name of the search for a greater "good" ok? I still think the answer is unclear.

After all, the whole premise of Jacob's belief system comes from a woman who killed his real mother in the name of protecting an island. Again, killing for a greater "good". It doesn't sit well with me. I can see how they are trying to make it as Jacob/God and MIB/Lucifer but I think they are also raising a lot of interesting questions to go along with that idea. Is MIB really wrong to want to go home? In essence, his real life was indeed robbed from him. His mother was killed, he was stolen from his people, lied to and told that there was no life off the island and then his "mother" tried to kill him to protect an island. I am unclear as to how that man is "bad." Yes, his actions once being thrown down that river of light are "bad", but I believe his "mother's" actions and Jacob's actions have been just as bad in trying to protect the island and find a replacement. Anyway, I think there is no real, good or bad here. I think that both Jacob and MIB have good and bad in them, just like the rest of us.

I'm a little annoyed that I have more questions than answers at this point with only 1 episode left. What the french! Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window