Re: LOST 5/11
Posted 5/12/2010 6:55:17 AM by Teachergal


Posted by MrsRbk

I don't think either brother is "bad".

The smoke monster is the evil one. Just needs a human form which makes it seem like the MIB was the bad one.

I think that the place it came from where the light is, is the source of where all good and evil in the world comes from. By throwing his brother into that cave Jacob unkowningly released the evil.



I agree with this. I have a hard time believing that when MIB was a child and then a man in his early 30's living with the other people that he was 'bad'. Yes, he was secretive and independent, but that's more free-will than bad. If you think about it, the "mother" was worse! In the name of the island, she kills people- the real mom, all the other people in the camp and who knows who else before Jacob and MIB arrived on the island. This is just like how Jacob brings people to the island to test their humanity- if they don't pass they either die or their lives turn awful. How is THAT not bad? MIB, as the smoke monster, is killing in the name trying to return 'home' whereas Jacob/"mother" kills in the name of the island. Who is the "good" one in this scenario? I think it is very murky trying to decide. I'm not sure.

Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window