Re: LI C-section rate among state's highest
Posted 4/24/2010 1:11:50 PM by Lillykat


Posted by Kidsaplenty


Posted by KateDevine


Posted by Lillykat


Posted by sleepie76

I read this article yesterday, I was shocked at

Chat Icon Long Island's obstetricians pay the highest malpractice premiums in the state, $178,000 a year, Chat Icon



Keep in mind though when something does go wrong it is often like a severely brain damaged baby who will need care for the rest of their lives in a facility which costs millions over that child's life. OR as is sometimes the case the mother dies - leaving behind young children that need care and she was a contributor to the family living so the end settlement or judgment can be VERY high for her loss and the loss of that salary. Other fields that are less risky pay less b.c they are less likely to have a larger judgment against them. Also keep in mind not all doctors get sued. You might have one with several suits for several dead mothers while another OB has never been sued or was only sued for a minor infection. We really need to UP the quality of doctors out there b.c with what insurance pays the doctors for the visits AND the malpractice costs more people who would be better doctors are now shying away from the field when they are needed the most.



I agree with Christine here.

I worked on a case with a brain damaged baby and a multimillion dollar verdict. Guess what, the parents weren't vacationing in Fiji that money was for the daily care of their child and the Court decides how it is paid out so that it is used for the appropriate thing.



But working in that field you saw the worst case scenarios, not everyday, run of the mill, maybe the Ob could have waited a bit cases, kwim? You worked on cases where the neglect to treat the patient in a timely manner was unquestionalbe, right?

You weren't seeing cases where the OB tells a Mom she's having a 9lb baby but it comes out at 7lbs. Or where a failed induction leads to a c-section, or they schedule a c-section because the mother has narrow hips (which is very very rare btw)

A lot of people contribute the rise in c-sections to doctors who are cut happy. I'm sure there are some out there, who prefer to just do a c-section so they don't have to wait around for delivery. But I also think the rise in the rates is due to the increase of pitocin and epidural use.

Women are laying flat on their backs for most of labor, not moving, or helping gravity push the baby down. This also prevents babies who are posterior (sunny side up) from flipping to anterior. All of these things contribute greatly to the rise in c-sections, and it is sad that more women aren't researching their birthing options. Most spend more time researching strollers than actually taking a lot at the data out their and making an informed decision with their health provider.



Well yes in some instances but I also had the opportunity to speak with in house doctors who are experts in the area who would speak with us (not just on cases but just as a general conversation). While 2 lbs off is not good (the general rule is that sonos IF the person know what they are doing are supposed to have a +/-1 rate of error (not 2 or more lbs).

But yes those are all things that DON'T help. There are also times when the doctors advise their patients to HAVE the sections but the mother want that to hold out b.c they know their bodies only to end up with a bad problem and a damaged baby and they cry but you should have forced me to have the section.

While what you speak of I'm sure does happen which is why it is important to KNOW your doctor and trust their medical advice if you pick a good doctor they are going to steer you only to have a section when it is medically necessary. The problem with a lot of the statistics is that they don't take into account medical necessity versus elective sections. With mothers having children later in life, GD, preeclampsia, larger babies, obesity on the rise - you have more mothers who are higher risk and therefore automatically more likely to need a csection as opposed to maybe a younger, mother with no health issues and a normal uncomplicated pregnancy.

The statistics can also be a bit misleading too - and can't be looked at in a vacuum. You also have to look at the hospital individually. You will see a place like Columbia Presbyterian has a higher rate of csections than many other hospitals. It is the top hospital for babies and a teaching hospital for that reason you get many people coming from all over with many medical issues that make it more likely they might need surgery. Also if you look at some of the "lesser" hospitals you have more OBs who might not be as experienced and missed certain red flags so they have been sued more and therefore are more likely to recommend surgery quicker b/c they might have had dead mother's or severely brain damaged babies in the past.

I for one went into labor on my own. My water broke shortly after arriving at the hospital and it had merconium in it. My contractions got weaker and weaker, I was dilating too slowly and then stopped altogether, my DD wasn't descending, and finally she turned sunny side up, on top of that WHILE I was in the hospital my BP spiked and I became preclampsic while I was there. So when the high risk OB looks panicked and says I strongly need to think about a csection in the next hour or two (after being in labor for over 24 hours). The panicked look was all I needed. I wanted a healthy baby. My sonos were right on - so right that the OBs even guessed during my surgery before pulling her out the exact pound and ounce she would be when she was born.

I think it would be much more interesting to see the statistics laid out - by medically necessity versus elective. I am NOT btw in favor of elective csection - I feel they should be reserved for medical necessity. But it also drives me crazy when I hear someone say - well you don't know if you let it go maybe you would have dilated and she would have come out. Yes maybe - but at what cost? The NICU? brain damage? shoulder issues? etc?

BTW I also have nurses and doctors in my family and family friends who are doctors so I have heard stories from all sides. I'm not saying that I don't think that there aren't issues - just that there are many contributing factors and only a select few issues are being looked at and not the whole picture in general.
Print Post      Close Window