|
Re: The truth about CIO - one more spinoff
Posted 4/20/2010 11:08:49 PM by clwp Edited to say: Okay, realized reading though 7 pages, this may not be a safer thread. OMG! PS. My take on the "studies" are that you can find anything you are looking to find in a study. How many "studies" have been retracted recently - should we dare go into VACCINATIONS lead to autism? I also think sometimes the folks that come up with the "guidelines" and the hypothesis they are looking for are old men... no little kids and anti-working mom's. Sorry, but it seems that way. You can say BFing is best, some say whatever is best for mom and baby to bond (and sometimes that is NOT BFing) is best. Neglecting a baby? I don't think anyone is neglecting a baby. Babies in my experience don't always cry b/c there's a problem... it's what they do. Many people were held and coddled and have anxiety and many do not, many of us who did cry young b/c thats what parent's did back then some of us have those issues, some don't. Additional edit: if letting a baby cry is neglect, I'd love to hear what would be said about having 2 under 2. There were times I felt s guilty b/c #2 would wake up and cry when I was in the middle of a diaper change or other issue #1 had. I spoke to my pediatrian about it and he said "you can never be to your second what you were to your first". I think letting a baby cry a few minutes is not neglect... a few hours yes, that is neglect. I doubt anyone on here does that. While a sibbling is supposed to be a gift, it's a lot harder for a mom of 2 to run to the newborn if the first child is young. I just thought of all this. I think there has been an upheaval of parenting that was concerning such as TV as a babysitter and such. So to combat that, they went the other extreme and say TV is off limits under 2 years of age. I'd love to see someone tell a 3 year old they cant watch Sesame Street b/c their baby sibbling is in the room. I think whatever brings a family as a whole less stress, be it an hour of TV or sleeping... that is what wil create a less anxious child. Reality is there is no recipe.. coddling a baby doesn't necessarily equal a mentally healthy child. I also disagree that at say 2 months old it's unhealth for a child to sleep through the night and younger than that be allowed to cry for a few minutes... not an hour, but 2-15 minutes while warming a bottle and who doesn't have to pee pee themselves before running to baby - unless you co-sleep. I won't go down the co-sleep road... I totally disagree with doing it and not for "cruel" or selfish (ok) reasons. Again, how many times did my #2 cry for a few minutes during the day b/c #1 hit her head on something and needed emergency attention. It happens, they get over it. So I guess my #2 will be an anxious mess... I'll make sure I have a good mental health plan to cover the costs of ruining her b/c her older sister could have had a concussion or pooped through her clothes. I did sleep train in a sense by not running right to baby at the first wail in the night basically from day 1, and it worked for us. Both kids are great sleepers, mind you at this point if they do cry at 23m and 9m at night I DO absolutely run to them b/c I can. The pattern has been established... now yes, if they cry there is a problem they are communicating. I couldn't listen to my toddler cry out for "ma-ma"... that would kill me more than an infant wail. I knew they were safe and ok and what they needed, they just hung out a few minutes while I took care of those needs. Selfish, well I was always told how well behaved my DD#1 is, so I guess it is selfish b/c I'm proud. Anyone who thinks CIO in any of it's forms is selfish hasn't done it, it can be a lot of work no matter what method you use. No shortcuts? CIO is a shortcut? I'd think co-sleeing is a short cut more than training a child to sleep on their own. No offense. |