Re: Holding your kid back in school - Help for a friend - added add'l info
Posted 4/14/2010 8:40:34 PM by 2girlsforme


Posted by nov04libride


Posted by jes81276

TO be honest, I don't think there is much of a leg to stand on. I know that my principal would never agree to just hold a child back because of age....this conversation should have been had before the child entered kindergarten....in my school there is usually a discussion if it is a late birthday about the possibility of holding a child out of kindergaretn for an extra year.
I don't think a parent can just decide to hold a kid back, I'm not positive, but I'[m pretty sure. Also, OT and AIS services are minimal compared to the extent of services that are offered. There is no reason to keep him back based on those services.



ITA. As a taxpayer and educator, i do not support parents holding children back without the support of the district. Chat Icon It's OUR money paying for his additional year, and unless it is absolutely necessary, I don't support the decision.



I know this is the way it would go down in my district as well.

However, he is a boy which I think makes a difference and he just makes the cutoff in most LI districts.

If I were in your friend's shoes I would hold him back, or at least push the district to do so. There will never be an easier time to retain him and frankly I see no down side at all. If he continues to need help he would have needed more help in the next grade and if he doesn't then she made the right decision.

In terms of social embarrassment he really is to young to be embarrassed. I wouldn't make a deal about it and just explain that he will be in class X next year.

In this part of the country, I think we tend to forget that in most other areas, the kindergarten cut off date is anywhere from May 1 through Sep 1.
Print Post      Close Window