Re: Spinoff to Spanking: Embarassment as Form of Discipline
Posted 4/13/2010 7:06:54 PM by brownie


Posted by maybesoon


Posted by Elizabeth

Your sister should stay out of it. Way out of it. If the neighbor asked her opinion, that's one thing but to talk to her about it when she's not abusing her kids in any way shape or form (based on what you said), I cannot see any parent taking kindly to that talking to. Especially if your sister happens to have younger children/less children/a husband who is around more....or whatever. I don't see the neighbor's behavior as so shocking or provocative. My first line of discipline? Probably not but I don't see her as doing anything horrible. If she actually spanked the kid in front of people, that would be one thing but to threaten it? And the kids fall in line? Ha! Why is that so horrible? It's very easy to say what we'd do and not do or what people shouldn't do when we are not in their shoes.

As far as giving "the look" - I also got the look as a kid. What does the look mean? What kind of trouble is the kid in when he or she gets home? If it's something that makes the kid behave, perhaps the trouble at home is going to be worse than being told in public they will be spanked...not all kids respond to a secret threat (in this case the look) of what will come later. Sometimes they need immediate punishment. So what about removing the child and giving them a time out? Wouldn't that be embarrassing to a 7 year old? So that's another form of humiliation I guess? I just think the judgement is a bit much.



ITA , everyone parents differently, as long as noone is beating the kid, what does it have to do with me?! if someone had the nerve to say something to me about the way I discipline, I would be furious and tell that person where to go Chat Icon



ITA
Print Post      Close Window