Spinoff to Spanking: Embarassment as Form of Discipline
Posted 4/13/2010 4:19:10 PM by secretmama

I am in 'hiding' to protect the identity of my sister who is afraid her neighbor (not a member of lifamilies) will see this, because I am sure people have nothing better to do than search for my postsChat Icon Seriously, she is afraid that she will see it and get upset with her, and I would not want that.

Here is the situation. My sister lives next door to a woman with 4 children under the age of 8. Her husband is often away (for work) so she spends a lot of time on her own with the kiddies. I can only imagine how tough that must be. Let me say that I by no means believe this woman physically abuses her children. She says that although she has spanked them, she uses it as a last resort. HOWEVER, she does use the threat of spanking while in public to keep her kids in line. She has told my sister that she thinks humiliation is a great form of discipline. She seems to intentionally try to embarass her children in public to stop their behavior. Last summer at a block party she said to her 7 year old daughter (in front of a group of her neighborhood friends) that if she kept it up she would be taken inside and given a good spanking. (This was in response to a 'fresh' remark her daughter made. I do not recall the actual remark but don't believe it was earth shattering). My niece is the same age as one of her daughters and they play together often. My niece has witnessed the spanking threats quite a few times and has actually told my sister she is afraid of Mrs. X because of this. My sister said just a few weeks ago at the bus stop in the morning she threatened to take her daughter (who was arguing with her younger brother) over her knee for a spanking (loud enough for all the children at the bus stop to here, and apparently there were some snickers).

I was spanked as a child, and I am not anti spanking. However, my parents handled spanking as a very private matter. Even though I knew I had a few friends that were spanked, I would have been embarassed if they ever witnessed a threat. My sisters feels badly for this woman's children, and she feels badly that her daughter is now uncomfortable around this woman as a result of these remarks. Should my sister say something to her, or is it none of her business/and not a big deal since they are just threats?

I am NOT judging, just wondering, does anyone else use embarassment as a form of discipline?
Print Post      Close Window