Re: Study: Spanking Kids Leads to More Aggressive Behavior
Posted 4/13/2010 2:40:07 PM by CookiePuss


Posted by Ophelia


Posted by QTDimps23


well said! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon i was never hit as a child and i am very against it. i dont see how it teaches the child not to do what they did wrong...except instill fear.



let me first say that I respect your decision completely.

I just want to bring up what I feel is a valid point. people talk about hitting only serving to instill fear. that it teaches nothing.

but what about things like time outs and taking away toys?

does that not also instill fear? it's just not fear of pain. it's fear of punishment. how does that "teach" anything more?

if you're not listening to mommy, how does 5 minutes in the corner teach any more of a lesson than a lil swat to the bum?

(I am genuinely asking here) Chat Icon



For me, time out teaches that there is a consequence to behavior. It doesn't instill fear but rather illustrates that my child has the ability to make a decision for herself and that decision has a certain affect. I don't believe that spanking will do anything other then have an immediate reaction. I don't believe that is has the ability to help to her to learn to make better choices.

ETA: I should also answer that in regards to taking away toys, I will start using that to affect behavior when the concept of earning it back can be utilized. I believe that when you take an item away or lose a priveledge, the only way to get it back is to earn it back.
Print Post      Close Window