Re: Study: Spanking Kids Leads to More Aggressive Behavior
Posted 4/13/2010 2:39:59 PM by Ian&EmmesMommy23


Posted by CrankyPants


Posted by Ophelia


Posted by QTDimps23


well said! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon i was never hit as a child and i am very against it. i dont see how it teaches the child not to do what they did wrong...except instill fear.



let me first say that I respect your decision completely.

I just want to bring up what I feel is a valid point. people talk about hitting only serving to instill fear. that it teaches nothing.

but what about things like time outs and taking away toys?

does that not also instill fear? it's just not fear of pain. it's fear of punishment. how does that "teach" anything more?

if you're not listening to mommy, how does 5 minutes in the corner teach any more of a lesson than a lil swat to the bum?

(I am genuinely asking here) Chat Icon


For me, I am comfortable teaching my child that there are repercussions for your behavior; I'm not okay with one of those repercussions being pain.

Also, IMO, time out or being sent to your room teaches a child to be reflective and that is something that I want to instill in my child.




exactly. sorry, i should have been clearer that i dont want my child to fear that i will hurt them. i remember as a kid if my mom pointed her finger at me i got really upset. i knew i did something wrong.

of course this is a purely personal decision and i would never tell someone how to raise their child. but for me, ive talked to too many friends who have been hit and their response is always "well i was a bad kid and i deserved it". who says you deserved it? i personally dont think any kid deserves to feel physical pain.

i want to explain what they did wrong and make sure they understand that. im not totally dense that there is a good chance that wont work. but at that point ill search high and low for an alternative.

ive witnessed parents hitting their children without explaining why their being hit. that just angers me. these kids have no idea what they did wrong. it makes me sad for them.

ETA: my DH was hit as a kid and when he got old enough he started laughing at his mom when she tried to hit him. what does that say? ha ha im bigger now you cant hit me. so basically hitting him instilled no values in him other than...i cant wait till i get older and you cant do this to me anymore.
Print Post      Close Window