Re: Please I need advice girls.....
Posted 4/12/2010 9:46:20 PM by mooshyboo


Posted by staceyd


Posted by Palebride


Posted by colette

Are you ok with a differing opinion??? Here's my $0.02... (*I also have a family member who suffered TERRIBLY for years with anorexia and bulimia so I am *highly* sensitive to the eating disorder background that prompts this threadyour concerns Chat Icon) but...
I think you're chasing your tail on this one... You can TRY to excise the word "fat" from your SIL's vocabulary when she's around Hannah, but does that really achieve the goal here?? Firstly it probably won't work-most people at some time or another label themselves with that word, whether it's real or perceived.... So if it's your SIL today it could be your MIL tomorrow, your teenage cousin next month, the lady on line at Friendly's next week, you get the point. It's not practical to try to shield Hannah from hearing it, both from strangers or family members.
Secondly, it may pizz off SIL, I don't know how sensitive she is or what your relationship is like...
Lastly, the word itself is not the problem... allllll the work you do now with Hannah to create a strong sense of confidence, the priority you place on eating healthy and exercising, as well as dealing with frustration and disappointment, will be WAY more effective than any vocabulary management you can do on anyone outside of your home. Most eating disorders are a symptom of a desire for CONTROL, not a "cosmetic" issue (though that's more often than not the catalyst). So those "life skills" you teach her will have the biggest impact in years to come.

Of course if you ever heard Hannah calling herself or anyone else "fat" that would be heartbreaking, and would deserve a long chat about self-esteem and labels, etc. But for now she's just an innocent little kid - who's BOUND to hear inappropriate stuff every day that she's out in the world.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I agree with Colette here.
You can't eliminate the words....but you can change her perception of the words. You can help her to see herself as a beautiful person on the inside, no matter what is on the outside. And you can show her how words can be hurtful. Use it as a time to teach, rather than to stifle.



I agree with this too... society is constantly deciding what is "pretty" and what is "desireable"... I think your job is to teach her the extent to how hurtful the word can be... so she knows it is usually inappropriate word to say... Kids will be kids and they will say things that we disapprove... but in my mind... as long as she understands and doesnt use it in a hurtful way.... you have done your job as a mom..



I agree with Collette & Stacey toooo....
Print Post      Close Window