Need advice/thoughts/opinions (long)
Posted 3/7/2010 11:28:14 AM by headoverheels

A little background: my parents are Jewish, and I was raised Jewish. DH's parents are Catholic but are not practicing at all (they haven't been to church since 9/11). DH and I are both agnostic, have been since long before we met, and have agreed to raise our children agnostic.

My mother told me that she wanted to buy DD her first piece of jewelry. She mentioned either a Chai or a Chamsa (which is shaped like a hand, it has roots in Islam but has very deep meaning for Jews as well). Before discussing it with my DH (which is my own fault, I fully admit that) I told her that I would prefer she get the Chamsa because for me, it has a spiritual and not a religious meaning.

When I discussed it with DH, he said that he sees the Chamsa as being a religious symbol and he compared it to DD wearing a cross. While I don't necessarily agree, I understand his reasoning and can also see that other people could view it the same way.

I called my mother and told her that after discussing it, we decided we did not want DD to have a Chamsa and we hoped she could find something else. My mother disagreed with "our" reasoning and compared the Chamsa to the Italian horn (of which I do not know the meaning of at all). I reiterated to her that this is what we had decided, and that was that. I could tell she was VERY irritated.

My parents have known since before DH and I even got engaged that we would be raising our children agnostic. They have never, ever given me grief about it, never made a snide comment, nothing. We celebrate all the big Jewish holidays with them and the Christian holidays with my ILs and it's never been an issue - my parents even joined us at the ILs for Christmas Day this year.

I feel terrible right now, very guilty, that I am allowing my mother to make me feel badly for siding with my husband. I don't want this to become an issue in the future. Obviously from now on, anything remotely religious will be discussed with DH first and foremost...

I don't even know what I am looking for, I am just upset with my mother for making me feel bad, like I am rejecting her religion or something. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window