|
Re: Private/Catholic vs. Public
Posted 3/4/2010 9:18:58 AM by Eireann
OK! ~As Catholic educator: The two schools in which I taught were fantastic. Of course there's a state curriculum! My high school students took all of their Regents. The high school is relatively small...around 800 students. There were computers in every classroom and by the time I left (3 years ago May) there were smartboards in 50% of the rooms and now 100%, I believe. (I am not one that believes that "gadgets" make a better school or a smarter student though.) The science lab was state-of-the-art. We offered at least half a dozen APs (I taught one!). 99.9% of the students went on to college...all kinds too...from Bronx CC to Fordham to Harvard. The scholarship opportunities were plentiful; and the study abroad programs were as well. All of the teachers in MY department were certified...most of them permanently. One of our English teachers was a former principal. We had a TON of extracurricular activities and the school spirit was unreal. As others have mentioned though...if a child was learning disabled, etc. these schools would definitely not be your first choice, although I do think "smart" kids would be challenged. ~As a Catholic school student/spouse/parent: I never felt I was short-changed. Yes, I failed the Math Regents as a freshman, but guess what...I got a tutor, studied over the summer and passed in August. I never did become a math genius. But I did take honors English (throughout) and History. I think my high school was pretty top tier for any high school--public or private--around here. It was competitive to even get in and then you had to maintain a 75% average. I wasn't a "joiner," so I have nothing further to say about that. Although, trust me, this is a school always in the paper for sports, etc. I went to college, got a BA, got an MSEd; I never felt like a dope...in fact, I usually feel smarter. My DH attended Catholic grammar, hs, and college. He received a full scholarship to college, won the Golden Key (which is sort of like the valedictorian of your major) in History in a very large university, got a full scholarship to law school (plus a grant for books!), wrote the model answer on the Bar exam, got an LL.M from NYU and has published three law articles and a website...so far. Oh, and is a practicing attorney, a business owner and a law professor! So much for middle of the road (although I do definitely see the validity of that statement by a previous poster.)! As parents...do you think my DH and I would remotely be interested in sending our DDs to a school that we felt wouldn't give them a great education?!! If we see them not learning to their fullest potential, we will definitely look into after-school programs etc. etc. etc. I also think maybe we'll start to see Catholic schools become more competitive academically and extra-curricularly as a result of the mass closings. They need to find a way to stay relevant. I think that--of course--there are good and bad public schools AND good and bad Catholic schools. I also think success depends mostly on parental involvement and the student him or herself. Good luck in your search! |