Re: Are my children Hispanic?
Posted 2/26/2010 1:26:04 PM by NinaLemon


Posted by Michmouse

It always perplexes me when people who were born in the USA identify themselves as another ethnicity....My ancestors came here from France, Germany, Ireland and Puerto Rico but I am an American and that is my first thought when people ask about origin. I have always taught my students that they are Americans as well and some of them say ""Nooo... My mommy said I am Irish!" Yes, Of Irish descent of course, but really...American.Chat Icon



It would bother me if a teacher said this to my son. Lineage, ancestry and nationality are family matters and often very close to the heart. A teacher does not know when the family came over, how strongly they identify with ancestors, etc.

Yes, we are all Americans, that is pretty much a given, we are here, but if asked my ethnicity on American soil I offer my ancestry. Why else would someone ask, they know I am American. If I am abroad, I answer American.


To the OP, I would think the answer to the question is up to you, there is hispanic heritage, so checking the box is accurate Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window