Re: Jewish ladies: Bris Question
Posted 2/24/2010 8:24:24 PM by LoveyQ


Posted by LML

I know that when you get a child christened or baptised you are promising to raise that child in the christian religion. Does the same thing apply to a bris? I thought that it was welcoming a boy into the Jewish religion, but DH doesn't seem to think that is the case.

Some back story is that I was raised Catholic, but I'm not really religious and I don't want to have a baptism. DH was raised Jewish and is much more religious than I am. He really wants to do a bris if we have a boy. We had agreed to raise our children by educating them in both religions and letting them choose later on. If a bris is welcoming the child to the religion then I really don't want to do it.

I'm also wondering if it's unheard of to do the circumcision in the hopspital and just performing the ceremony in front of family. I just don't understand why everyone has to watch it happen and I'm really uncomfortable with it.



I'm not Jewish, so I'm sure someone with more knowledge and experience will post... but from what I know, I do not believe you are promising to raise the child Jewish if you have a Bris. I know someone who is Catholic and married a Jew. They had a Bris and later on they also had a baptism.

Also, I do not believe it is ok to do the circumcision in the hospital if you are having a bris as that is part of the bris... but again, someone with more knowledge can clarify.
Print Post      Close Window