Re: If you work in manhattan but have a house in LI
Posted 1/27/2010 5:55:08 PM by Coosie

DH works in Manhattan and we live in Massapequa. Thankfully, his job is literally across the street from Penn Station. But from house door to work is about a 60-75 minute commute (depending if he gets the express train or not). So most nights he takes the 5:40 train home and is walking in the door just a bit before 7pm.

I ask him all the time if he likes it or not. At first he HATED it! He used to work in Jericho but then got transferred to the NYC office. It took him a while to get used to. Now he tells me that he doesn't mind it so much because he doesn't have to sit in traffic and pay attention to the road - he can just sit on the train - read, play his PSP - catch up on work - sleep - whatever.

The down side is that he always complains about that you lose that ability to just jump in your car at your own schedule to come or go. Now you're stuck on the trains schedule and if there's delays there's nothing you can do about it. It also makes it hard for him to do anything at night because even though he is leaving work at 5:30, he's not getting in until close to 7 - then he eats, unwinds, etc and now its close to 8pm. So it makes it a bit tough.

On top of that there is the price for the monthly ticket. For him, it's about $230/month (and he doesn't use the subway so make sure you factor that part in if you are not within walking distance to Penn). But with the price of gas, depending on what type of car you drive that might equal out.

HTH! Good Luck!
Print Post      Close Window