Re: Spin Off to Bumpers - SIDS
Posted 12/13/2009 2:32:20 PM by itsbabytime


Posted by LoveyQ

I just want to say that just because someone (or even a large number of people) didn't have something bad happen when using bumpers, does not mean that the risk for SIDS is not there. I'm sure THOUSANDS of people have used them without any incident (thankfully!), but that doesn't mean your next child or someone else's child won't be the one that dies from SIDS.

I'm not trying to be rude or flame anyone, but it's important to know what increases your risks. And yes, it's totally up to each person to do what they like and prefer with their child/ren, and I am not a parent yet, so take what I say with that in mind, but I also know that wherever I can, I will try to reduce the risk of something like this happening to my child. I know that if a number of different professional organizations say this is a risk, I don't personally care how many people didn't have something bad happen - I only care about how many did.



I understand what you are saying but, as a BTDT mommy let me try to explain why this all or nothing approach might not work in practice and why some mommies are posting that they have not stuck to these rules - and OF COURSE it is not b/c they want to risk their child dying!

The thing is - in practice sometimes the exact opposite of this is actually safer for your child. For example,, my DS had reflux. Now, b/f I had him when I read about this I thought it was some rare thing and oh, my DS wont have that - well, let me tell you, more than half the babies i know have it. The poor baby would never sleep and would cry whenever i put him in his bassinet or anywhere else flat on his back. Well when I told his ped this - on the board of pediatrics at NYU - he actually told me to get the positioner and use it all the time. I mentioned to him what I had read on this board that it was a sids risk and he said that was never proven, somewhat outdated and that it would be far more harmful to my DS NOT to use it. We moved a few months later and I asked our new ped and he said the exact same thing.

I had the same situation with the bumpers. By the time my DS went into the crib - he was 4 months old. He was rolling from birth practically so by that point he was a very aggressive roller. I put him in the crib and the first night and nap time I could hardly sleep b/c I kept hearing his little head it the wooden rails. I asked the ped about it and he said to definitely put the bumpers back in. He said as long as he could move (roll) and lift up his head with no problems the bumper did not pose any problems at all. My ped has been around for well over 30 years so I trust his judgement. I certainly wasn't going to risk my baby injuring his head repeatedly, or getting his limbs stuck etc. for some theoretical risk that even my Ped said was not a concern.

So, my point is these things are great to know but, in reality, from an actual mommy, they might not be the safest things for YOUR child.
Print Post      Close Window