WWYD- Gift Related...
Posted 12/11/2009 3:21:34 PM by kahlua716

We do a Secret Santa with DH's family. I purposely traded with someone to get my BIL because I had a cute idea.

I had found these sterling silver personalized dog tags online and thought he would like something as a memento of his daughter- who is his life (He and his baby mama are no longer together so no one else would think to get it for him)

So, I ordered it and only slightly exceeded the $40 limit.

It arrived yesterday. Although it is nicely done and good quality- it's TINY and doesn't look like it's worth the $40 I spent. (the dimensions weren't posted on the site- I just assumed it was a regular sized military dog tag)

So- my dilemma- do I get him something else to go along with the necklace? I'm SUPER broke and really can't afford to, but I feel kinda silly giving this dainty necklace to him.

In case it matters- this BIL is currently living with us rent free, along with my niece on weekends Chat Icon

I just don't want to look cheap...

External Image

ETA: I emailed the seller earlier:

Hi!
I recently ordered a dog tag necklace for my Brother in law. I am very impressed with the turn around time and the quality- however, you should put the measurements of the tag on your site. I was under the impression that they were the size of regular military dog tags. This was for a secret santa gift with a $40 limit, and I feel that it looks cheesy to just give him a tiny thing. Again- thanks for the quick shipping and great work- I would just make it clear that these are “mini” dog tags on your site.
Thanks!



She responded right away:

Just send them back, the photo on the website with my husbands hand/wrist is a good size gauge in my eyes. Your concerns are noted, but I never get complaints so this hard to swallow for me...


Chat Icon

What to do....

Here is the pic she is referring to

External Image

I guess she has a point...but I'm still disappointed.
Print Post      Close Window