Re: WWYD? Long
Posted 11/30/2009 6:48:50 PM by MrsProfessor


Posted by Atlast07

How is it possible to deny one student a field trip over another? I understand your concerns, and I think that it is a good idea to ask if someone from home (a guardian of sorts) would be able to accompany her on the trip but I think it may be illegal to deny this to the child. I am not trying to be controversial but it sounds like this child has some issues that need to be worked out that stem pretty deep. I just know in my school we aren't allowed to deny any students the right to go on a field trip that the rest of the class is going on unless their parent/guardian does not grant them permission.



To be honest, it's never been an issue to deny a student who I don't feel is deserving. I've kept kids off trips for less, and have never heard that doing so is "illegal." There have also been occasions where I have wanted to take a child on a trip and my principal said no. Usually I work it into my reward system and only the kids who met the criteria are allowed to go, though I didn't do that with this trip.

I work in NYC and we seldom have buses for trips. This means a 15-20 minute walk to the subway and taking the train. And I do agree that this student has some problems- all the more reason to hesitate to take her out in a situation like a trip involving the subway. A former colleague once took a child out who she had concerns about- and this kid took off. It took hours to find her. I won't take a chance that this will happen to me- even with chaperones, periodic head counts, etc., anything can happen.

As for this situation, I did make the offer that her mother could accompany her which my admins approved.
Print Post      Close Window