Re: Child Seats and the Ages of Children
Posted 11/25/2009 5:12:04 PM by SweetTooth


Posted by MrsRivera

I'm sorry if this is an ignorant question, but...my DD is almost a year, and she's SO tall that her legs actually bend now when she's in the carseat--she can't stretch them out straight.

I had planned on putting her front-facing on her 1st birthday, if nothing more than to finally give her legs some space. I just don't see HOW I can keep her rear-facing any longer when her legs are ALREADY bent at about a 30-degree angle... Chat Icon

AND we have a large SUV, so I can't even blame the size of the car for the cramped space!




"What about my child's legs?"



One of many car seat related myths is that a rear facing child is at risk of broken legs when rear-facing. The reality is this: any crash severe enough to break the legs of a rear-facing child is enough to severe the spinal column and kill a forward facing child. There has never been a documented case of damage to the legs, hips or internal organs when rear facing.

On the other hand, the single most common injury for FORWARD facing children? Broken legs.



"What about comfort?"



Children are rather odd creatures, they find comfortable positions that would land the average adult in traction. Most children simply prop their legs on the back of the vehicle seat, or cross them. Many children actively prefer rear facing.



"My child suffers from car sickness."



While there are a few cases in which turning a child forward facing relieves travel sickness, it really is a toss up. There is no guarentee that doing so will relieve your child's symptoms, and the evidence that it can harm your child to be forward-facing too soon is overwhelming. While being car-sick is a miserable experience for parent and child alike, it's extremely important to remain rear facing.





"My child hates riding in the car!" or "My child is miserable rear-facing."



You will, over the course of your child's life, have to make many decisions which will make your child unhappy.



Safety issues are non-negotiable. You would not allow your child to play in the Wal-Mart parking lot the Saturday before Christmas, would you? Of course not! Choices regarding your child's safety seat are just as important and should not be influenced by what the child desires.



My preschool-age daughter would love to eat chocolate cake for every meal. That would make her happy. But it would not be a healthy choice for her.



That said, if your child only knows what it's like to be rear facing, there is no evidence that turning him or her forward facing will make them happier. Many children actively dislike forward facing. There is no support for their legs and if they drop something (like their favorite "lovey", or a sippy cup), it hits the floor rather than landing in their lap where it can be retrieved easily.

http://www.cpsafety.com has an album of older rear facing children.
Print Post      Close Window