Re: Couple Busted for refusing to pay tip
Posted 11/19/2009 10:31:51 PM by smdl


Posted by DiamondGirl


Posted by smdl


Posted by DiamondGirl

I think this is ridiculous...

No way should the cops have been called.

I don't agree with not leaving a tip....I mean I wouldn't leave 20% for bad service but nothing? I would be too embarrassed not leave anything.



I think the issue is that it was a mandatory gratuity.

I would leave nothing for bad service.

And the way they described their experience, I would have dropped the charges immediately if I was the manager. I think the guy wanted to play hardballs by forcing them to pay the tip and called the cops. Admitting they provided very poor service. That's being very greedy. In this economy, you will lose customers fast. It's one thing to have your customer pay you for the food. But as a manager, sometimes you have to admit your weaknesses and that was one of them. He should have appologized. As long as they paid for the food, he should have dropped it. The person assigned to their table never offered a refill, brought napkins, etc... That really poor service. Busy or not!!! They were not walking out without paying. Just not paying for the service!



I agree with you, it isn't like they didn't pay for dinner--what's the issue? Tips are not mandatory (well unless it is a group of 6 or more or whatever)

Personally I would leave something bc I would feel wierd leaving nothing--but you are right if the service is THAT bad they really dont deserve any tip!



it was a mandatory gratuity of 18% so they could not leave whatever they wanted either.

I don't know how legally this can stand. Any lawyers want to jump in???? It was probably written somewhere on the menu.

Can you argue the gratuity if you feel you did not get the service you wanted AND the Manager concurs their service was not at their best that night?

Maybe the couple should have called the cops too and file a complaint for charging them for service they did not provide or not up to par?
Print Post      Close Window