Re: NEW MOM/ CIO
Posted 11/5/2009 10:32:33 AM by MrsS2005


Posted by headoverheels


Posted by KateDevine


Posted by HomeIsWithU

I had posted something similar when DS was around that age and almost everyone said you should not let a newborn CIO.

I'm going to say, from MY experience, that letting him cry for a few minutes isnt a big deal. My PEDs opinion is that you CAN spoil a newborn and that you should not teach them to become dependant on you to fall asleep. We didnt listen (rocked him to sleep and ran to him if he cried) and now at 3 months DS needs to be rocked to sleep all the time and it takes a minimum of 20 minutes and multiple rocking sessions to get him down for the night Chat Icon I'll be doing CIO at 5 months with him because his bedtime routine is ridiculous.

I know a lot of other posters on here will disagree with letting a baby cry for 5 or so minutes, but most of our parent's and grandparents generation did it and we all turned out just fine. I wouldnt let him cry for 10 or 15 minutes, but 5 minutes to give him time to get it out of his system and fall asleep on his own? I dont see the big deal.



I'm not flaming you, but I just want to say that 3 months is still sooooo little, and they are so tiny and need so much then. There is really no need to rush things...

I totally get doing CIO with an older child--I did it--but enjoy the rocking and the cuddling, it doesn't last foreverChat Icon



i have to agree with Kate here - sorry Chat Icon

while i highly disagree with your ped about spoiling a newborn Chat Icon that's really not the issue. there is just so much time to break "bad" habits like rocking and cuddling, i don't understand what the rush is. i would love to be able to do that with DS now, but he is go go go all day long and if i get 5 minutes of cuddle time that's a lot!

i completely understand letting a baby fuss or even cry for a few minutes if it doesn't move to hard crying or hysterics, and it helps them put themselves to sleep. we all know that every baby is different. but CIO is totally different.


ITA. It's one thing to let a newborn fuss before going to sleep. It's completely different to let a newborn CIO and get all worked up. You cannot spoil a newborn and you are not creating bad habits by catering to his or her needs. As your baby gets older, usually around 6 months, he or she will learn to self soothe and if you need to, you can try CIO then.
Print Post      Close Window