Re: Should an 8 year old have...
Posted 10/6/2009 8:20:12 PM by browneyedgirl


Posted by bri1980


Posted by browneyedgirl

no way.

there should never be an "emergency" for an 8 year old. 8 year olds should always be with an adult whose job it would be to handle the "emergency". no 8 year old is mature enough to handle any type of emergency and shouldn't be in a situation without supervision.




What about the other poster who said their child takes the bus and sometimes they run late? Wouldnt you want your child to know you were on your way? So they dont get scared?



i haven't read the entire thread.

if my child's bus is running late, i can call the school or district transportation to find out. why would my kid get scared because his bus is late? i do not want my 8 year old to have to feel "responsible" to check in with me when he's on his way home from school or anywhere else. a bus is driven by a competent adult--if there is a flat tire or accident, he/she will contact transportation who will then contact all the parents. as a teacher, i've seen it happen.

if i'm running late to pick up my child from the bus, i can call a relative/neighbor/responsible adult to meet him at the house. in my district, the child would NEVER be allowed off the bus if i or another adult wasn't waiting for him. so even if i called him, it wouldn't matter because he'd have to ride the bus back to school until i could go get him.

there is no reason for my 2nd or 3rd grader to ever be in a situation where they are the responsible person. and i would be fooling myself if i really thought my 8 year old son was only going to use the phone for "emergencies".
Print Post      Close Window