Re: Can they force me to
Posted 9/18/2009 8:08:59 PM by stickydust
Posted by mrsej
Posted by JTK
Posted by mrsej
Posted by JTK
Posted by mrsej
I think a health care field there needs to be precautions, especially if you are working with sick patients (neonatal unit). the religious exemption won't work where the hospitals argue they have an overriding public health interest. The government has, and needs to have, some authority to temporarily suspend rights during emergency situations. If they declare this an "emergency situation", they can demand people get the vaccination, religious exemption or not.
ok.. so i'm going to respond to this since i am in fact a NICU nurse. our patients are very unique in that they have never been outside the hospital.. they are born in the hospital or they are transferred there in an incubator.. not really exposed to outside viruses. They are exposed to the nurses and doctors ect. that care for them .. and whomever the parents choose to allow visit them. Now, the governor wants the nurses to be immunized due to the fact that we may get the virus "from" our patients (near impossible on my unit) and then in turn bring it home to our community, further spreading the virus. Tell me this... why do WE have to protect ourselves and our patients but THE PARENTS can come in unvaccinated and bring everyone ELSE in unvaccinated. This is about our freedom. WE should have the right to refuse.. is this NOT America???? (sorry for the caps.. they are not directed at you, i'm just in an outrage over this!) Healthcare workers are not the ones spreading disease.. we wash our hands more than most of the rest of the public. They are targeting the wrong group
Based on the lecture I went to, the fear is that the nurses and/or doctors would infect the patients, not the other way around. Also, hospitals have the right to screen visitors and not permit them to come into the hospital if they are visibly ill. Whether they do this or not, I don't know. DUring the lecture, it was cited that roughly 60% of healthcare workers didn’t get shots, even though studies have suggested this can reduce the ICU mortality of their patients by up to 60%. I personally think that hospitals are worried about having enough people to work if this does reach a pandemic state. I think the medical facilities are really concerned about who is going to take care of the patients if half of the staff is out sick.
i know what you are saying and have to say i disagree with the findings 100%. We don't get the flu shot statistically, but we aren't getting the flu. The visitors are NOT screened unfortunately, people come to visit their sick and dying loved ones when they have the common cold of course not thinking of their immunocompromised state. most don't even understand the risks of transmission and i hardly EVER see them wash their hands on other units. Nurses and doctors WILL be in shortage this year for sure.. but I don't think it'll be because of the flu. You have no idea how many healthcare workers are refusing this vaccine. I was told by the commisioners office yesterday that they recieve thousands of phone calls and letters EVERYDAY! Personally, i think there will be a change in the legislation. Maybe some of us will lose our jobs over it but at least we will still have our rights.
I agree with what you are saying about the visitors. That was actually touched upon at this lecture and the lecturer stated "visitors are not being paid by the hospital, the medical staff is. Also, the medical staff has a ethical/moral obligation to protect vulnerable patients from a transmittable disease" - I work in the legal field, not the medical. Whether or not this is the right mandate - I couldn't tell you. However, legally, in the courts, there is nothing that can be done. Like you said, the challenge needs to be made at the legislature. IMO, I don't think there is anything wrong with mandating the flu shot - I can see people's opposition to the H1N1 vaccine.
I think the other point is that medicl personnel have a duty of care for the patients whereas visitors do not. In addition, in the event a patient becomes infected - if said patient contracted the flu from a hospital employee then the hospital faces liability for that.
With respect to this being a violation of privacy it is not. First off, there is actually no constitutional right to privacy. Secondly, you are not being mandated unequivically to get the vaccine. You only have to get it if you want to continue to work in healthcare. It is the same as saying that the government cannot require you to get any vaccine but you cannot attend public school.
Lastly, as someone who has been a patient in a hospital many times I would be completely livid if a hospital allowed any of their employees to not be vaccinated and that employee infected either myself or my children (if they are patients). I think that to the extent you are medical personnel then you have to submit yourself to this for the good of the patients.
I really do not understand the outrage over this when the alternative can be something so serious such as infecting and possibly killing a premature infant in someone's care.
|